| 1984: Bill Fisher | 2004: John Metzgar, 41 | |
| 1985: Jay Haug | 2005: Sean McCormack | |
| 1986: Ron Borsheim | 2006: John Metzgar, 43 | |
| 1987: Bryan Bartosik | 2007: John Metzgar, 44 | |
| 1988: Ron Borsheim | 2008: John Metzgar, 45 | |
| 1989: Tom Graham | 2009: Bill Phillips, 54 | |
| 1990: Bill Fisher | 2010: Justin Jacobs, 27 | |
| 1991: Mark Kathman | 2011: John Metzgar, 48 | |
| 1992: Adrain Lilburn | 2012: John Metzgar, 49 | |
| 1993: John Benkert | 2013: John Metzgar, 50: | |
| 1994: Denise Metzgar | 2014: Bruce Holmes, 65: | |
| 1995: Rex Reed | 2015: Kathleen Kaye, 56 | |
| 1996: Lee Yaracs | 2016: Bill Phillips, 61 | |
| 1997: Gary Myers | 2017: Bill Phillips 62 | |
| 1998: Frank Reynolds | 2018: Bill Phillips 63 | |
| 1999: Mark Kathman | 2019: Bill Phillips 64 | |
| 2000: Max Minter | 2020: Chris McCaffery 32 | |
| 2001: Bruce Holmes | 2021: Neil Chandler 47 | |
| 2002: Mark Kathman | 2022: Neil Chandler 48 | |
| 2003: Bruce Holmes | 2023: Bill Phillips 68 |
2024: Jonathan Hulzebos 28